“Flipped” Metal Oxide Cage Can Sort CO2 from CO

A Japanese research team led by Kanazawa University studied host-guest interactions in vanadate clusters. V12 is a spherical bowl that hosts small molecules in its interior. The team created empty (guest-free) V12 for the first time. One of the 12 units of VO5 was found to flip inwards to fill the void vacated by the guest. Empty V12 could absorb CO2 capturebut rejected CO, offering a way to separate these molecules for CO2 capture.

Kanazawa – How do you separate carbon dioxide from carbon monoxide? One way, showcased by a new study from Kanazawa University, is to use a bowl of vanadium. More precisely, a hollow, spherical cluster of vanadate molecules can discriminate between CO and  CO2, allowing potential uses in  CO2 storage and capture.

At the molecular scale, small objects can fit inside larger ones, just like in the everyday world. The resulting arrangements, known as host–guest interactions, are stabilized by non-covalent forces like electrostatics and hydrogen bonds. Each host will happily take in certain molecules, while shutting out others, depending on the size of its entrance and how much interior space it can offer the guest.

One such host is V12 – a rough sphere made from 12 atoms of the transition metal vanadium, connected through 32 oxygen atoms. The bowl-like structure has an opening at one end, with a width of 0.44 nanometers, perfect for letting in the right molecule to nestle inside the cavity.

“V12 accepts a range of guests on the scale of small organic compounds,” says Yuji Kikukawa, co-corresponding author of the Kanazawa study in Angewandte Chemie. “In fact, it’s rather hard to isolate an empty V12 by itself. While the host stabilizes its guest, so the guest returns the favor – if we remove the guest, the host quickly replaces it with another molecule.”

Each vanadium atom in V12 forms a square-pyramid with five oxygens. The oxygens of each VO5 point outwards, while the positive charge from vanadium fills the inner cavity, helping to stabilize electron-rich (or anionic) guests. However, the Kanazawa team created a guest-free V12 for the first time, by using a solvent—acetone—whose molecules are too bulky to fit through the entrance.

To make up for the missing guest, the empty V12 bowl did something unexpected. The VO5 unit at the bottom flipped inwards, like an umbrella inverting in heavy wind. Now, the host cavity was filled by the negative terminal oxygen of the single “upside-down” VO5. This atomic shifting to accommodate a new structure, termed a polytopal rearrangement, had never been seen in metal oxide clusters. The structure transformation could be monitored by infrared spectroscopy.

“We then took the empty V12 and explored which guests we could insert back into the bowl,” says the authors. “Nitrogen, methane and carbon monoxide were all rejected, but carbon dioxide was readily taken up. This immediately suggests a way to separate CO2 from other gases.”

In fact, V12 and  CO2 proved such a perfect fit that  CO2 could be inserted even at low atmospheric pressure. V12 might therefore be an ideal solution in CO2 capture to combat climate change, and even in  CO2 storage for the emerging technology of artificial photosynthesis.



Figure 1.

Anion structures of CH2Cl2(guest)-inserted V12 (left) and guest-free V12 are shown. Orange and red square pyramids represent VO5 units with their bases directed to the center of the bowl, and the inverted VO5 unit. Green and black spheres represent Cl and C, respectively. Hydrogen atoms of CH2Cl2 are omitted for clarity.


Figure 2.

IR spectra of CH2Cl2 -inserted V12 and guest-free V12 are shown in black and red spectra, respectively. The peak position in the highlighted region of guest-inserted V12 and guest-free V12 is different due to the VO5 unit inversion. The spectra of guest-free V12 are recorded under atmospheric pressure of CO2 (blue) and CO (green) at 25 ºC. From the peak position,  CO2 can be interacted with the V12 bowl inside, while CO show no interaction with the bowl inside.



Solid-State Umbrella-type Inversion of a VO¬5 Square-Pyramidal Unit in a Bowl-type Dodecavanadate Induced by Insertion and Elimination of a Guest Molecule

Journal: Angewandte Chemie

Authors: Yuji Kikukawa, Sayaka Uchida, Sho Kuwajima, Yoshihito Hayashi

DOI: 10.1002/anie.201809120

This work was supported by a JST PRESTO Grant (No. JPMJPR1655), Japan, JSPS KAKENHI Grant (No. JP18K14239), and Collaborative Research Projects of Laboratory for Materials and Structures, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo Institute of Technology.