Next generation solvent contributes to next generation biofuel production from biomass

Abstract:
Compared to first-generation biofuels produced from foodstuffs, production of second-generation biofuels for daily use is an urgent issue. In this study, a novel carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion was developed as a solvent of biomass, which could dissolve cellulose with very low toxicity to microorganisms. Use of this novel solvent enables significant reduction of energy cost for ethanol production from non-food biomass. Thus, second-generation biofuel ethanol production is in sight of practical implementation.


[Background]

The first-generation biofuel, industrialized, ethanol, is produced from foodstuffs like maize, and thus poses great concern about a possible future shortage of food. It is therefore necessary to produce ethanol from non-food biomass like weeds, waste paper, paper cup, etc. (second-generation biofuel ethanol). Solvents needed for the production of second-generation biofuel ethanol known so far are highly toxic to microorganisms. In order to remove such highly toxic solvents, complicated processes are necessary, such as washing with water, separation by centrifugation, compression, etc. As a result, the energy recovered in the ethanol so produced is less than that required to produce it, i.e., there is a negative energy balance (more production of ethanol imposes more load on the environment). It was considered impossible to solve this problem, since a harsh solvent was needed to break down recalcitrant plant materials like cellulose, while such a harsh solvent would kill microorganisms (with fragile and very vulnerable cell membranes) that play essential roles in the fermentation necessary for producing ethanol.


[Results]

In the present study, researchers of Kanazawa University, Japan, attacked this problem; they succeeded in reducing the toxicity to microorganisms by developing a novel solvent, a carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion*1, for dissolving biomass cellulose (Figure 1). The EC50, the concentration of a substance that reduces the growth of Escherichia coli to 50%, was found to be 158 g/L for the newly developed carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion, whereas the EC50 of ionic liquid*2, one of the conventional solvents of cellulose, was 9 g/L. This indicates that the novel carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion shows 17 folds lower toxicity than the ionic liquid.  

With Escherichia coli that can produce ethanol, fermentation ability was examined and revealed to be almost maximal in 0.5 mol/L carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion with a final ethanol concentration of 21 g/L. On the other hand, the same experiment with the ionic liquid produced only 1 g/L ethanol. Thus, fermentation in the presence of the carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion produced 21 times more ethanol than that using the ionic liquid. 

In another experiment, bagasse was used as a starting plant biomass for ethanol production without washing/separation processes. Fermentation in the presence of the carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion produced 1.4 g/L ethanol, while no ethanol was obtained with the ionic liquid due to its high toxicity (Figure 2).

With these experimental results, it is shown that, using the carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion, plant biomass could be converted into ethanol in a single reaction pot without washing/separation processes. This should be a big step forward in the production/utilization of second-generation biofuel ethanol through reducing large amounts of energy input.


[Significance and future prospects]

Besides the first-generation and second-generation biofuel ethanol, a third-generation biofuel, a kind of oil, may be made from some algal species. In order to obtain such a third-generation biofuel from algae, polysaccharides like cellulose, which are main components of cell walls, have to be dissolved. The energy efficiency would be much increased if dissolved polysaccharides could be converted into ethanol. Further development of our current study would significantly contribute to the production of not only second-generation but also third-generation biofuel ethanol.

Furthermore, a lot of attention has been attracted by the unique characteristics of the carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion, and three international collaborations are currently going on, one of which is with Rutgers University, U.S.A.

 

Figure 1. Novel solvent, carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion, for plant biomass, developed in this study

After dissolving plant biomass by the novel solvent, carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion, hydrolysis and fermentation were consecutively carried out in one reaction pot for conversion into ethanol.

 

Figure 2. Consecutive ethanol production with the ionic liquid or with the carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion

With the ionic liquid (left), no ethanol production was observed while with the carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion (right), ethanol production was observed.

 

[Glossary]

*1 Carboxylate-type liquid zwitterion
Newly developed solvent that can dissolve biomass (cellulose) with low toxicity to microorganisms. The difference from ionic liquid is that the positive charge and the negative charge are covalently bonded. This liquid zwitterion is the second one to be reported, but this is the first that has a carboxylate anion.

*2 Ionic liquid
Salts that are liquid below 100 ºC. They consist of various pairs of positively charged and negatively charged ions, and specific ionic liquids are known to be able to dissolve biomass and cellulose efficiently.

 

Article
Title: Design of Wall-Destructive but Membrane-Compatible Solvents
Journal: Journal of the American Chemical Society
Authors: Kosuke KURODA, Heri SATRIA, Kyohei MIYAMURA, Yota TSUGE, Kazuaki NINOMIYA, Kenji TAKAHASHI

Doi: 10.1021/jacs.7b08914

Funders
COI program "Construction of next-generation infrastructure using innovative materials –Realization of a safe and secure society that can coexist with the Earth for centuries", Advanced Low Carbon Technology Research and Development Program (ALCA, No. 2100040) by Japan Science and Technology Agency and (JST).Cross-ministerial Strategic Innovation Promotion Program (SIP) “Structural Materials for Innovation” by Council for Science, Technology and Innovation (CSTI) (Funding agency:JST) ,.Government of Japan; and Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (No. 15K17867).